Skip to main content

Madras Café Review: John Abraham can't act but go watch it!

Directed by Shoojit Sircar, Madras Café, stars John Abraham and Nargis Fakhri in lead roles. The backdrop of this film catapults you straight into the centre of the civil war in Sri Lanka during the 1990s. As a film viewer from South India, I do not feel that the movie attempted to ridicule or insult Tamilians as is being suggested by many. The narrative is conducted as neutrally as possible and with tremendous sensitivity.

You will be gripped by an overwhelming sense of anger, despair and pain as you are taken through some heart rending scenes of how the Tamils were persecuted in Sri Lanka
Some of the most disturbing scenes in the movie present a very different view of India’s political endeavors to manipulate and take control of the ethnic conflicts between the majority Sinhalese and minority Tamil population there. 
It also shows how vested powers from across the globe strategically pushed forward their vested economic interests to end India’s ‘peace’ attempts by masterminding the assassination plot of India’s former PM at the time – Rajiv Gandhi.
What I liked most about Madras Café is that it portrays a highly sensitive issue such as the ethnic persecution of Tamils and the dynamics that led the LTTE to plot the PM’s assassination without any attempt to cater to any particular section of the audience. 
The film does make a sincere attempt to take a neutral and objective stand on the incidents that led up to the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi including the portrayal of the team that prepares itself to do so – there is no condemning of their acts or any attempt to kick up political mileage of the same. 
Madras Café Review: John Abraham can’t act!
John Abraham dons the role of Vikram Singh, who is a member of India’s intelligence service and he is deputed to Sri Lanka to help the two warring factions reach a peaceful resolution that suits India’s political interests. Nargis Fakhri plays the role of a war journalist whose reach is far and wide and whose network sources seem to be more accurate and advanced than India’s top intelligence agencies.
The first glitch is this – From the initial scenes to the last scenes in the movie, John Abraham disappoints totally. A drunken, disheveled John Abraham who relates the most shocking episodes of his life to a priest fails to impress. He fails to act unless you count wooden expressions behind cooling glasses as ‘acting’! His brief stunt as a drunken man is such a dud that you want to throw up. He cannot convince anyone that he is working for RAW – his expressions, body language and dialogue delivery are so pathetic that you would want to cry in despair at a fine film being torn to shreds by an actor’s inability to act. 
Perhaps an actor like Abhay Deol or Arjun Rampal may have elevated this film to a masterpiece with some brilliant portrayal.
The second glitch is this – poor star cast. This film has all the right ingredients except the star cast. 

Even Siddharth Basu disappoints in his portrayal of the character he is playing. No actor in this film except perhaps the actor who plays the role of “Bala” stands out as a striking performance.
Madras Café Review: My Verdict
The much talked about issue of how Madras Café has portrayed LTTE is really going over the top. The LTTE seem like a bunch of Robin Hoods in this film as compared to the reality of what things were like at the time. So this is what I have to say– the Tamils shouldn’t take this movie as anything than what it is – a thriller movie.
While Madras Cafe has not shown us the complete story, it attempts to do so with sensitive restraint and without putting us through unnecessary songs or ‘masala’ scenes.
I’d rate Madra Café as a movie that attempts and fails at giving us serious portrayal of Indo-Sri lankan political history.
At many levels, the movie will shake you up – but it won’t topple you down. The star cast lets you down but the narrative, the plot and the storytelling doesn't. Go watch it!

Comments

Friendship SMS said…
Sometimes, you need a good director to extract out the best from an actor, who is praised for everything except acting skills. Madras Cafe has been made in such a way that it has extracted the best out of John, perhaps for the first time, who is often praised for his physique and looks rather than acting skills. Even, Nargis manages for deliver a good performance in this excellently told story. A must watch for the connoisseur of good movies make such bold subject oriented films succeed commercially as well, which are usually and unfortunately not given their due. Well done MC team!
@Friendship: Thanks for reading this review and for sharing your thoughts on it. The good thing about books and movies is that we all relate and experience it differently even when the content is the same. Madras Cafe has attempted to extract the best out of John and I agree on that point. Where I differ is that I am more certain that while John gave it his best shot, a better and more talented actor would have done more justice to this movie. But hey, thanks a ton for stopping by to comment. I appreciate it.

Most Popular Posts

The Ugly Truth about Caste in Kerala

Many years ago, when I wrote this post on Kerala's caste system, I had not considered that people would start sending in abusive comments about one caste over the other. It baffles me that this is how Indians, all of us, continue to judge each other on account of caste differences.  [ READ: Guru Kripa: Powerful Lessons at the Lotus Feet ] My question is - why do you ABUSE any caste or community? I suggest that you read about the lives of great Masters and their stories - none of them judged anyone on the basis of caste.  You can read the life stories of Sri Adi Shankara Bhagawadpada, Tulsidas, Jnaneshwar, Namadev, Sri Aurobindo, Sri Ramakrishna, Swami Paramahansa Yogananda, Shirdi Sai Baba, and many more Gurus in Sanathana Dharma. NONE of them endorse these caste hierarchies in Bhakti Marga. Assuming that Guru Sampradaya does not appeal to your sensibilities, do read this  new book 'Ants among Elephants' written by Sujatha Gidla, who writes about herself as being born

How do you light Deepam at home?

How do you light deepam at home? As a child, I loved watching the ritual of my grandmother lighting the deepam or the traditional lamp at home in the evenings. A sense of serenity accompanied her frail figure as she would carefully straighten every wick, dip it into the tiny puddle of oil and light the lamp. As my grandmother would read out the scriptures and chant the prayers, the fragrance of incense sticks and flowers added depth to the experience. In many Hindu homes nowadays, the lighting of the lamp (or the nilavilakku, as Malayalis refer to the traditional lamp in their homes) is not a regular practice. A lot of people have many questions around how to light deepam at home and which oil to use and so on. An important point to keep in mind - Maintain physical cleanliness and hygiene while lighting the lamp. Wear clean clothes while lighting the lamp. Frequently Asked Questions About Lighting Deepam at Home Collating most queries related to how to light the deepam at home, I'v

Note of Thanks for the Honest Award

Thank you, Baba . I've run out of words to describe my happiness in getting this Award. A big, heart felt thank you to Faiza Ali for encouraging me with this Honest Award. It means so much to me because I'm an ardent admirer of her awesome blog, Faiza Ali's Kitchen. Requirements:- I must thank the person who gave me the award and list their blog and link it I must list 10 honest things about myself I must put a copy of Honest Scrap logo on my blog I must select atleast 7 other worthy bloggers and list their links I must notify the bloggers of the award and hopefully they will follow the above three requirements also. 10 Honest things about me:- 1. I am very proud of being an Indian. 2. I am very thankful and humbled by my parents', their unconditional love, sacrifices and amazing support and the way they brought me up. 3. Good books are my life. 4. I love my Twitter friends. 5. My favorite place is Puttaparthi. 6. I am a shopaholic. 7. I am a 'people person.&#

Saree Woes 2

Our earlier discussion on Saree Woes really perked up my spirits. A big thanks to all of you for pepping me up. Okay, here's the good news. There was an unexpected late night party that I had to attend in Gurgaon. To be honest, I haven't had the time or energy to attend any such parties after Adi was born. I was sure I wouldn't have the confidence to make conversation with the glitterati, let alone feel confident to carry off wearing a saree. This is one of those parties where you have to be dressed very formally. Well, at the end of a working woman's day, you hardly feel ready to attend one of these parties looking like a moron, right? So, with very little preparation and very few hours left, I called on all the gods in Heaven to help me look a little younger and prettier since I don't have the magic to look young all on my own. Although I was tempted to wear one of my awesome Kancheevaram treasures, I knew it would be very difficult to drape it without any h

Sorry Tales of Housework

While growing up, I shirked house work because I knew Mummy would do it. The only hard work I did is to eat whatever she made. Mummy would wake up early in the morning, bathe, do the pooja, make breakfast and lunch and then of course, my task was to eat it away as if nothing else matters.  Of course, she would ask me to help her out and learn some basics but do you think I listened? Not seriously, I simply didn't. I used to tell her not to worry so much. I always felt there would be a magical Alladin's Lamp that would manifest and take care of everything when it was my turn to take care of a home. Her wise words "Start early, or else later you will find it difficult to manage simple chores in your home" always fell on my deaf and dumb ears. Those were the years I wish I could turn back time.... (sigh, dreaming, dreaming!) In case you are wondering why the sigh, read this post .  Marriage, Introspection and the Pressure Cooker Suddenly, I found